The Fifth Down

President's column:
To print (media guides) or not to print?

You've lived the scene: In the press box above a darkened stadium, clock ticking toward deadline, looking for one elusive factoid to complete the story.

You turn and ask the guy sitting next to you, but he's got the same deadline and no answers. And then you start flipping through a well-worn media guide.

In the happy ending, you find the fact, file the story and head home, lugging the media guide along.

But maybe you've heard: Those days might be ending. The media guide in those situations and others, a sportswriter's best friend is fast becoming an endangered species.

In this issue of The Fifth Down:
President's column: To print or not to print
FWAA to name "Super 11" SID's
FWAA creates ethics panel | FWAA Code of Ethics
Gangi: More than meets the eye in future of media guides
Media days hit by economic woes (includes master schedule)
All-America Checklist (.pdf)

More than two dozen schools, including big names like Michigan, Ohio State and Wisconsin, will not print media guides for the 2009-10 school year. The Pac-10 has proposed NCAA legislation to eliminate printed media guides as a way to cut costs. The Big 12 has endorsed the idea. The Big Ten's big boys have done it, and that league is leaning the same way.

It's going to be on the Internet, they tell us. Everything's going online anyway, right?

But if the thought of dealing with erratic wireless on deadline doesn't concern anyone, there's also the added task of finding the information on those convoluted, complicated school Web sites. Does anyone think these things are going to be uniform in setup?

We could debate whether getting rid of media guides actually saves significant cash, or whether it's a shortsighted move that might cost the schools publicity. Doesn't matter which, because it's happening, and the movement seems to be growing.

The good news, and there is some, is a proposal from the Southeastern Conference to the NCAA. Schools would be allowed to print media guides, but could not send them to recruits.

"The intent is it would be a media guide," said SEC associate commissioner Charles Bloom.

You know, like they once were. Like pro sports teams still produce. Bios of players and coaches, historical records, etc. No need to show the waterfall in the weight room, the air-conditioned lockers, or the fantastic beauty of the co-eds.

Looking for Outland, Nagurski Watch Lists?
This season the Outland Trophy Watch List will be unveiled exclusively on ESPN's "College Football Live" in August as part of a two-week rollout dedicated to the awards that appear in the "Home Depot ESPNU College Football Awards Show" in December. The Bronko Nagurski Trophy, which is not part of the program, will also release its watch list next month.

When media guides became part of the recruiting arms race, they got thicker than a metropolitan phonebook. The NCAA limited the number of pages to 208 several years back, but didn't solve the problem. Some guides are almost exclusively dedicated to recruiting.

Meanwhile, the rushing records can't be found.

So removing the recruiting sections would be nice. Media guides for Olympic sports might still be a casualty o f the economy, but football and basketball guides would remain. Schools could continue sending them to boosters and selling them to fans for keepsakes. But they wouldn't need to be nearly as elaborate, and the costs would go down.

Also, the all-time rushing stats might find their way back into the books.

This is a good, well-reasoned proposal, and something we should get behind. Aside: Why is it that college football's most-covered league seems to get the need for media coverage?

"There was a feeling amongst the group," Bloom said, "that historically speaking, the media coverage we've been able to obtain, there's a positive relationship there. We didn't want to cut off the communication and relationship we've had with the media. Our group felt media guides are good media relations."

See? The SEC gets it.

Others don't. Or don't care. Or don't think they can afford to care in these economic times.

John Humenik, the executive director of CoSIDA, says the consensus among sports information directors he's spoken with is to favor the SEC's proposal. Humenik recently participated in a discussion at a meeting of the NCAA's recruiting cabinet, which is considering the various options. He believes the SEC proposal has a chance to gain traction.

But even if the SEC proposal passes, it wouldn't take effect until the 2010-11 school year. Also, it's not a mandate to produce media guides; some schools and conferences almost certainly would not.

We should applaud the SEC for its stance. I hope its proposal succeeds, and that schools see the need to continue printing media guides true media guides. If you agree, you can send your endorsement along to UCLA senior associate A.D. Petrina Long, chair of the NCAA's recruiting cabinet.

But it feels like too little, too late. The ship has sailed. We might slow it, but it's not turning around.

"No question, these things are going to disappear as we know them," Humenik said. "It's not a question of if it's going to happen. It's when."

So here's something that might help: The AT&T Cotton Bowl is planning to partner with to produce a DVD with 131 media guides all 120 Football Bowl Subdivision (I-A) teams, plus the 11 conference guides as well as the NCAA record book, rule book and statistical manuals, provided to all FWAA members. Each conference would receive a number of DVDs to distribute to media, as well.

You could download all of the information to your laptop, or carry the DVD in your bag. It wouldn't be on paper, an d for many of us, it wouldn't be nearly as easy as flipping through the media guide at least, not on deadline.

But it's a good option, and considering what seems like the inevitable demise of printed media guides, it might be the best available idea.

Otherwise, as those ever-earlier deadlines approach, we'll have to hope the wireless is working, and the Web site is up, and the information is presented online in a easily accessible, coherent fashion.

If not, we can ask the guy next to us.

George Schroeder of the Eugene (Ore.) Register-Guard is the president of the Football Writers Association of America. He can be reached at


Bert McGrane Award nominees: Mark Blaudshun (
Volney Meece Scholarship nominees: Dave Sittler (
Website, National Team of the Week: Ted Gangi (
Membership Directory: Charlie Fiss, Goodyear Cotton Bowl (
Ethics/Press Relations Committee: Kirk Bohls (
College Football Playoff Liaison: Gina Lehe, College Football Playoff (
Eddie Robinson Award: Steve Richardson (
Fifth Down Blog/FWAA Best Writing Contest: Ken Stephens (
Bronko Nagurski Trophy: John Rocco, Charlotte Touchdown Club (
Outland Trophy, All-America Team: Steve Richardson (
Super 16 Poll: Phil Marwill, National Football Foundation (
Orange Bowl/FWAA Courage Award: Matt Fortuna (
Freshman All-America Team: Mike Griffith (

September 2013 | .pdf
July 2013 | .pdf
February 2013 | .pdf
December 2012 | .pdf
October 2012 | .pdf
September 2012 | .pdf
July 2012 | .pdf
February 2012 | .pdf
December 2011 | .pdf
October 2011 | .pdf
September 2011 | .pdf
August 2011 | .pdf
February 2011 | .pdf
December 2010 | .pdf
October 2010 | .pdf
August 2010 | .pdf
June 2010 | .pdf
January 2010 | .pdf
December 2009 | .pdf
October 2009 | .pdf
August 2009 | .pdf
July 2009 | .pdf
January 2009 | .pdf
December 2008 | .pdf
October 2008 | .pdf
August 2008 | .pdf
June 2008 | .pdf
January 2008 | .pdf
December 2007 | .pdf
October 2007 | .pdf
August 2007 | .pdf
June 2007 | .pdf
January 2007 | .pdf
December 2006 | .pdf
October 2006 | .pdf
August 2006 | .pdf
June 2006 | .pdf
January 2006 | .pdf
December 2005 (.pdf)
October 2005 (.pdf)
August 2005 (.pdf)
June 2005 (.pdf)
January 2005 (.pdf)
December 2004 (.pdf)
October 2004 (.pdf)
September 2004 (.pdf)
June 2004 (.pdf)
February 2004 (.pdf)
December 2003 (.pdf)
October 2003 (.pdf)
September 2003 (.pdf)
July 2003 (.pdf)
March 2003 (.pdf)
December 2002 (.pdf)
November 2002 (.pdf)
October 2002 (.pdf)
August 2002 (.pdf)
February 2002 (.pdf)
December 2001 (.pdf)
November 2001 (.pdf)
September 2001 (.pdf)
August 2001 (.pdf)